A streaming stick or box takes a TV whose own apps have gone slow, stale or ad-choked and gives it a fresh home screen and a remote that responds. Picking one is mostly picking a platform: Roku, Amazon's Fire TV, Google TV or Apple's tvOS. After that, the spec sheet matters in a few specific places: whether it matches the HDR formats your TV can show, how well it holds Wi-Fi from across the house, whether it has a wired port, and whether you can talk to it without hunting for the remote. This comparison covers 19 sticks, boxes and one streaming soundbar from Roku, Amazon, Google, Apple, Nvidia, Walmart's onn and Xiaomi. The shortlist sits above this article, and the full sortable sheet lines them all up. Below, we go column by column, from the couch two rooms and one concrete wall away from the router.
The lineup: five Rokus (the Streaming Stick, Streaming Stick Plus, Streaming Stick 4K, Ultra and Streambar SE); five from Amazon (the 2026 Fire TV Stick HD and Fire TV Stick 4K, the Fire TV Stick 4K Max, the discontinued Fire TV Stick 4K Plus and the Fire TV Cube); the Google TV Streamer; two Apple TV 4K generations (the 2026 model and the discontinued 2022 one); the Nvidia Shield TV Pro; three from Walmart's onn (the 4K Pro, 4K Plus and 4K Streaming Stick); and two from Xiaomi (the TV Box S and TV Stick 4K).
Quick answers, if you stop here:
- Best overall: the Apple TV 4K (2026). Engadget calls it the best-performing streaming box you can buy, but it costs a lot more than it used to.
- Best value box: the onn 4K Pro (2026). Android Authority would pick it over the Google TV Streamer.
- Best stick: the Roku Streaming Stick Plus, Tom's Guide's best overall streaming device.
- Best for Amazon homes: the 2026 Fire TV Stick 4K, which Tom's Guide found fast, with Amazon's best remote yet.
Form factor: stick, box or soundbar
Nine of the 19 are sticks that plug straight into an HDMI port and hide behind the TV. Nine are boxes that sit on the stand, and one, the Roku Streambar SE, is a streaming player with small stereo speakers built in.
Sticks are the easy gift and the one to pack for a hotel TV. TechRadar called the Roku Streaming Stick Plus compact enough to take on the road, and most new sticks now draw power from the TV's own USB port. Tom's Guide says the 2026 Fire TV Stick 4K is the first 4K Fire stick that can, and PCWorld had no trouble powering the Stick Plus that way. Neither comes with a wall adapter, so an old TV without a powered USB port means buying one.
Boxes buy you room for ports, mics and faster chips. The bulkier sticks also don't always fit: TechRadar had to use the Fire TV Stick 4K Max's HDMI extender because the stick was too big to plug in directly.
Platform: the column that decides everything else
Six of the 19 run Google TV, five run Roku OS, three run Amazon's Android-based Fire OS, two run Amazon's newer Vega OS, two run Apple's tvOS, and the Nvidia Shield TV Pro runs Android TV.
Roku is still the simplest. Tom's Guide picks the Roku Streaming Stick Plus for its clean interface, and PCWorld likes Roku's dedicated play and rewind buttons, which Google TV and Apple TV remotes leave out. The trade is ads: PCWorld found animated banner ads in both the Home screen and the sidebar.
Amazon is in the middle of a switch. The 2026 Fire TV Stick HD and Fire TV Stick 4K run Vega OS, which Tom's Guide found smoother and faster than Fire OS. It only installs apps from Amazon's own store, though, so the Android sideloading that older Fire sticks allowed is gone.
The catch: if you sideload apps today, stay on Fire OS. That means the Fire TV Stick 4K Max or the Fire TV Cube, since Tom's Guide says the new Fire TV Stick 4K replaces both the 4K Select and the 4K Plus.
Google TV is the most open of the big platforms, and the cheapest route into it isn't Google's own box. Android Authority spent a month with the onn 4K Pro and came away preferring it to the Google TV Streamer. tvOS is the premium pick. Tom's Guide says the only ads you'll see on an Apple TV are for shows and movies, but it rates Siri the weakest voice assistant of the lot.
Max resolution: 4K is nearly the default
Seventeen of the 19 output 4K. The two that stop at 1080p are the Roku Streaming Stick and the 2026 Fire TV Stick HD, both aimed at older HD TVs.
That makes sense for those TVs, and nowhere else. Tom's Guide calls the Fire TV Stick HD the cheapest easy way to bring an aging TV online, but says to skip it if your TV is already a smart TV, because the built-in streaming is better. If your TV is 4K, start with the Streaming Stick Plus or the Fire TV Stick 4K instead.
Dolby Vision and HDR10+: match your TV, not the box
Thirteen of the 19 support Dolby Vision and 17 support HDR10+. These are the columns where you need to know your TV. If the player and the TV don't share a format, you fall back to plain HDR10.
The surprise is where Dolby Vision goes missing. The Roku Streaming Stick Plus, the 2026 Fire TV Stick 4K and the onn 4K Streaming Stick all skip it, per TechRadar, Tom's Guide and Android Authority. On Roku, PCWorld points out you have to step up to the Streaming Stick 4K to get it. The Nvidia Shield TV Pro goes the other way, with Dolby Vision but no HDR10+, per Nvidia.
Pay up only if: your TV supports Dolby Vision. If it only does HDR10+, the Stick Plus or the Fire TV Stick 4K already covers it, and the Dolby Vision models won't add anything.
Wi-Fi: the long-range test matters more than the version number
One player is on Wi-Fi 4 (the Roku Streaming Stick), six on Wi-Fi 5, nine on Wi-Fi 6, two on Wi-Fi 6E (the Fire TV Stick 4K Max and Fire TV Cube), and the 2026 Apple TV 4K is the only one on Wi-Fi 7.
That gap is the reason a Wi-Fi version alone doesn't tell you much. PCWorld says the better Wi-Fi won't matter where reception is solid, but it can on the fringes, and it's where I'd spend the extra money if your TV is a few walls from the router.
Built-in Ethernet: a wired port beats a better radio
Seven of the 19 have a built-in Ethernet port, all of them boxes: both Apple TVs, the Google TV Streamer, the Nvidia Shield TV Pro, the Roku Ultra, the onn 4K Pro and the Fire TV Cube. None of the sticks do. Roku says the Stick Plus works with powered USB-C Ethernet adapters, but PCWorld couldn't get it working with several hubs and points Ethernet fans to the Ultra instead.
Gigabit Ethernet, so the Google TV Streamer's wired port beats the onn 4K Pro's 100 Mbps one.
Android Authority says 100 Mbps is still plenty fast for basically all streaming. What matters is having the cable at all.
Hands-free voice: talking to the TV without the remote
Four of the 19 listen without a button press: the 2026 Apple TV 4K, the onn 4K Pro, the Roku Ultra and the Fire TV Cube. Engadget says the new Apple TV 4K has three far-field mics for Siri and processes that audio on the chip, out of reach of apps and Apple. The onn 4K Pro does the same with Gemini, and Android Authority notes a switch on the back that turns the mic off. On the Roku Ultra, the listening happens in the included Voice Remote Pro.
What the box won't tell you: a remote finder saves more evenings than an assistant does. The 2026 Apple TV 4K's Siri Remote works with Find My, which Engadget's reviewer credits for much less time searching, and the onn 4K Pro has a button that makes its remote chirp.
Which streaming stick or box to buy
Slopsheets says: buy for your platform and your TV's HDR format first, and only pay for a box if you'll use the Ethernet port or the hands-free mic.
For most people with a 4K TV, the Roku Streaming Stick Plus is the easy pick, and the Fire TV Stick 4K is its match in an Alexa house. Spend more on the Roku Streaming Stick 4K if you want Dolby Vision or if your Wi-Fi is weak where the TV lives.
If you want a box, the onn 4K Pro (2026) is the value champ, with Ethernet and hands-free Gemini. The Roku Ultra is the all-in Roku with the best remote. The 2026 Apple TV 4K is the fastest thing here, but Engadget would rather you hold out for a sale or keep a 2022 model if you have one. Tom's Guide still recommends the discontinued 2022 Apple TV 4K while stock lasts.
If you're building out the living room, the soundbars sheet covers the speakers these players feed, and game controllers pair with most of them for cloud gaming. If the TV is the problem, look at portable projectors too.
Streaming stick FAQ
Is a Fire TV Stick or a Roku better? It depends on what you want to see when it turns on. Tom's Guide picks the Roku Streaming Stick Plus for its simpler interface, while its Fire TV Stick 4K review found Vega OS fast and the new remote Amazon's best. Both put ads on the home screen, per PCWorld and Tom's Guide.
Can I play games on a streaming stick? Light ones. Tom's Guide paired a Bluetooth controller with the Fire TV Stick HD for Amazon Luna and Xbox Game Pass cloud games, and says the 2022 Apple TV 4K handles arcade titles. AFTVnews found only Nvidia's Shield TV devices and the Fire TV Cube beat the Xiaomi players and onn 4K Plus on graphics.
Can I AirPlay from an iPhone without an Apple TV? On a Roku, yes. PCWorld notes Roku supports AirPlay for sharing from iPhones and iPads, and its Featured Free menu collects free, ad-supported shows too.
Should I wait for the Fire TV Stick 4K Plus to go on sale? Only if you need Fire OS. Tom's Guide says Amazon replaced it with the 2026 Fire TV Stick 4K, so it's clearance stock now, not a current model.
Sources / further reading
- Tom's Guide: the best streaming devices
- Engadget: Apple TV 4K (4th gen) review
- Tom's Guide: Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K review
- Tom's Guide: Amazon Fire TV Stick HD review
- Android Authority: Onn 4K Pro (2026) review
- PCWorld: Walmart Onn 4K Plus review
- PCWorld: Roku Streaming Stick Plus review
- TechRadar: Roku Streaming Stick Plus review
- Cord Busters: Roku Streaming Stick review
- AFTVnews: Xiaomi TV Box S and TV Stick 4K benchmarks
- TechRadar: Shield TV discontinued, Shield TV Pro price rise
- The Verge: Roku raises streaming hardware prices