← All comparisons Toaster Ovens & Air Fryer Ovens · 16 models compared

Best Toaster Ovens and Air Fryer Ovens 2026, Compared: 16 Models from Breville, Ninja, Cuisinart and More

A spec-by-spec comparison of 16 popular toaster ovens and air fryer ovens on toast capacity, largest pizza, air fry, wattage, cooking programs and width, plus which one to buy for your counter.

PUBLISHED NOV 11, 2026 9 MIN READ
Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro (BOV900) Best overall

Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro (BOV900)

It matched a top basket fryer in America's Test Kitchen's testing and handles nearly every other job a countertop oven can.

Ninja 12-in-1 Double Oven with FlexDoor (DCT401) Best double oven

Ninja 12-in-1 Double Oven with FlexDoor (DCT401)

Two independent compartments, strong Consumer Reports results and excellent member reliability scores.

Breville Mini Smart Oven (BOV450) Best small oven

Breville Mini Smart Oven (BOV450)

America's Test Kitchen's small-oven pick, for people who want toast and baking without air fry or a big footprint.

Instant Omni Plus 19-Quart Toaster Oven Air Fryer Best value air fry

Instant Omni Plus 19-Quart Toaster Oven Air Fryer

Strong air frying for the money in America's Test Kitchen's testing, with a rotisserie included.

The shortlist

The picks side by side on the columns that decide it. The best value in each is tinted green.

4 picks · shortlist
Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro (BOV900)9.2 Best in column 9 slices Best in column 13 in Yes Best in column 1,800 W
Ninja 12-in-1 Double Oven with FlexDoor (DCT401)8.6 Best in column 9 slices From Tom's Guide's test: the toast program covers six slices, but nine fit and browned. 12 in Yes Best in column 1,800 W
Breville Mini Smart Oven (BOV450)8.1 4 slices 11 in No Best in column 1,800 W
Instant Omni Plus 19-Quart Toaster Oven Air Fryer7.2 6 slices 12 in Yes Best in column 1,800 W

the full sheet: 16 models, all columns, sortable → ai score is a model's read of the specs, not a lab test

A toaster oven is a small box with heating elements and a door. Add a fan and a mesh basket and the same box gets sold as an air fryer, a dehydrator and a proofing cabinet. Consumer Reports now counts about 60 rated toaster ovens with an air-fry mode, more than half of its latest ratings, so the feature has stopped being a way to tell them apart. This comparison lines up 16 popular models from Breville, Ninja, Cuisinart, Instant, Cosori, Panasonic, Black+Decker and Hamilton Beach on the six specs you can actually check: toast capacity, largest pizza, air fry, wattage, cooking programs and width.

The short version: the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro is the one to beat if you have the counter for it, the Ninja DCT401 double oven is the strongest choice for reliability, and the Breville Mini Smart Oven is the small one to buy if you never planned to air fry anything.

Slopsheets says: Measure your counter first, then decide whether you want air frying at all. Wattage and the program count separate these ovens far less than their boxes suggest. Width and toast evenness separate them a lot.

Toast capacity: the box number is a ceiling

Slice counts run from 4 to 9 in this group. The Breville BOV900 and BOV950, the Ninja SP101, DT201 and DCT401 all claim nine. The Black+Decker TO3265XSSD claims eight. The Breville BOV860, Cuisinart TOA-70, Ninja SP151, Instant Omni Plus and Cosori CS130-AO claim six. Everything else is a four-slice oven.

Those numbers describe what fits, which is a different question from what toasts well.

The mismatch runs the other way too. Tom's Guide found the DCT401 is only programmed for six slices of toast but physically holds nine, and it browned all nine. Per RTINGS' review, the Cosori CS130-AO fits six and browns them very evenly, though it is very slow about it. Reviewed got even toast across nine slices from the Ninja DT201.

Don't overpay for: A nine-slice rating, unless you make toast for a crowd. If you usually toast two to four slices at a time, every oven here can handle that.

Pizza size: 12 inches is the dividing line

Five models quote 13 inches: the Breville BOV900, BOV860 and BOV950, the Ninja SP101 and the Cosori CS130-AO. Seven quote 12, the Breville Mini quotes 11, and the three smallest (Panasonic NB-G110P, Black+Decker TO1313SBD and Hamilton Beach 31403) stop at 9.

Treat a 9-inch limit as a personal-pizza limit. A takeout-size frozen pizza needs one of the larger boxes, and the RTINGS result on the Ninja Flip is a good reason to leave an inch of margin. A low ceiling also matters more than the diameter for some food: Reviewed found the Ninja SP101 too short for a whole chicken, which is the usual trade-off with its slim, wide body.

Air fry: useful, with a known limit

Twelve of these 16 ovens have an air-fry mode. The four that skip it are the Breville Compact and Mini, the Panasonic FlashXpress and the Black+Decker TO1313SBD.

The honest expectation comes from Consumer Reports: in its evaluations, dedicated air fryers crisped better than toaster ovens, though the ovens hold more. Reviewed reached a similar conclusion and adds that these ovens tend to be harder to clean. There is one notable exception. America's Test Kitchen's August 2026 testing crowned the Breville BOV900, which matched its favorite basket fryer on fries and chicken Parmesan. Its basket offers nearly 175 square inches of usable space, enough for about 3 pounds of wings in one layer. ATK also rated the Breville BOV860 and Ninja DT201 highly, and made the Instant Omni's 18-liter model its budget pick for air frying.

Pay up only if: Air frying is the main job. A basket fryer is still the cheaper route to crispy food if you already own something that makes toast. Our air fryer sheet has the options.

Power: nearly everything is 1,800 watts

12 of 16
ovens in this comparison are rated at the same 1,800 watts, the most a standard 15-amp US outlet can supply. The spec can't rank them.

The exceptions are the Black+Decker TO3265XSSD at 1,500 watts, the Panasonic at 1,300, the Black+Decker TO1313SBD at 1,150 and the Hamilton Beach 31403 at 1,120. The last three are small ovens with less space to heat. The TO3265XSSD is the outlier, a wide oven on a lower rating. A high rating also says nothing about accuracy. GearLab measured the Black+Decker TO3265XSSD about 30 degrees cool at a 350°F setting, while the 1,800-watt Ninja SP101 reached 350°F in 1.8 minutes and stayed within about 7 degrees. If you cook cookies by the clock, that gap matters more than the number on the box. GearLab also found the Cuisinart TOA-70 running hot, despite near-perfect toast.

Cooking programs: count the ones you'd use

The box says

Twelve or 13 cooking programs, so it must do far more than an oven with eight.

The counter says

Most programs are the same elements and fan at different settings. Toast, bake, broil and air fry cover nearly every weeknight.

The range runs from 4 on the Black+Decker TO1313SBD and Hamilton Beach 31403 to 13 on the Breville BOV900 and BOV950. A few are real capabilities worth checking for: the Cosori lists rotisserie and fermenting, and the Breville Pro models add proofing and slow cooking. Many of the rest are shortcuts to a time and temperature you could set yourself.

The Breville pair makes the point neatly. On paper the BOV950 Joule and the BOV900 match on all six specs in our table. The Joule's extra money buys app control and three app-only heating modes, and RTINGS' side-by-side comparison actually leans toward the cheaper BOV900 for air frying.

What the box won't tell you: Consumer Reports gave the Ninja DCT401 excellent member scores for reliability and satisfaction, plus high marks in nearly all of its tests except reheating. That says more about what you will live with than a thirteenth preset.

Width: the spec that decides what fits

This is the column to read with a tape measure in hand. The Breville BOV900, BOV950 and Black+Decker TO3265XSSD all run 21.4 inches wide, roughly a third wider than the 15.75-inch Cuisinart TOA-70, Ninja SP151 and Instant Omni Plus. The Panasonic is the smallest at 13 inches.

Width is only half of it, so check depth and clearance too. The Ninja DCT401 is one of the narrower large ovens at 16.39 inches, but it is 18.6 inches deep. The Ninja SP151 and SP101 flip up against the backsplash when you're done, and Ninja claims that frees up about half of the counter space they use. You do need room behind and above them for that to work.

The catch: Leave breathing room. These ovens run hot on the outside, so check your manual's clearance figures before you build one into a tight spot under a cabinet.

Which one to buy

The sheet covers the full field, sortable by every spec above.

FAQ

Can a toaster oven replace an air fryer?

For many households, yes, if you accept a little less crisping. Consumer Reports found dedicated air fryers crisp better, while toaster ovens hold more food and handle toast, baking and broiling too. The Breville BOV900 is the rare one that matched a top basket fryer in ATK's testing.

Is a double oven worth it?

Only if you regularly cook two things at different temperatures, or want to avoid heating a large cavity for two slices of toast. Check the depth first: the Ninja DCT401 needs 18.6 inches of counter front to back.

Why does the Ninja Flip fold up?

It saves counter space when you aren't cooking. Ninja claims up to 50% less space when flipped, but the shallow cavity limits how tall your food can be, and RTINGS found limited vertical room inside.

Sources / further reading

More comparisons