Most single-serve coffee makers are bought for the first cup and judged on the fifth. The real differences show up later: which pods it's locked to, how big a mug it will fill, how often you're back at the sink with the water tank, and whether it can make a latte without a second gadget. This comparison covers 20 single-serve and pod coffee makers from Keurig, Nespresso, Ninja, Bruvi, Lavazza and Cuisinart. The shortlist sits above this article, and the full sortable sheet has every model side by side. Below, we go through it column by column and flag the specs that read better on the box than on the counter.
The lineup: nine Keurigs (the K-Mini, K-Express, K-Classic, K-Supreme, K-Supreme Plus SMART, K-Elite, K-Café SMART, K-Iced and the pod-plus-carafe K-Duo Hot & Iced Gen 2); seven Nespressos (the Vertuo Pop+, Next, VertuoPlus, Vertuo Lattissima and Vertuo Creatista, plus the Original-line Essenza Mini and CitiZ & Milk); the Ninja Pods & Grounds Specialty (PB051); the Bruvi BV-01; the Lavazza Classy Plus; and the Cuisinart Grind & Brew Single-Serve (DGB-2), which has a burr grinder built in.
Quick answers, if you stop here:
- Best overall: the Ninja Pods & Grounds PB051. It takes K-Cups or your own grounds, brews up to 24 oz, and has a fold-away frother.
- Best Keurig: the K-Supreme Plus SMART, the best-tasting Keurig in TechGearLab's panel and Good Housekeeping's Keurig pick.
- Best Nespresso: the VertuoPlus for black coffee, or the Vertuo Lattissima if you want milk drinks at the press of a button.
- Best-tasting pods: the Bruvi BV-01, CNN Underscored's top pick, if you don't mind buying pods online.
Which pods it takes: K-Cup, Vertuo, Original or something else
This is the column that decides what you'll be buying for years, so it comes first. Eleven of the 20 take K-Cups: all nine Keurigs, plus the Ninja PB051 and the Cuisinart DGB-2. Consumer Reports points out that K-Cups come in a much wider range of brands and blends than Nespresso capsules, and that variety is the main reason to stay in that system.
Nespresso runs two capsule systems that don't mix. Vertuo machines read a barcode on the capsule rim and set the volume and brew for you, which Good Housekeeping says makes brewing smoother than on machines where you pick a cup size yourself. The trade-off is that each capsule makes one size, so a bigger cup means buying a different capsule. Original-line machines like the Essenza Mini and CitiZ & Milk take the smaller espresso capsules.
The other two use their own pods. The Bruvi uses B-Pods that CNN Underscored notes you can only buy online, from Bruvi or its Amazon storefront. Lavazza says the Classy Plus takes its Expert capsules.
Slopsheets says: pick the pod before the machine. If you want grocery-store options, stay with K-Cups. If you mostly drink espresso-style coffee and milk drinks, Nespresso beat K-Cups on taste in TechGearLab's testing, but you'll be buying capsules from one company.
Biggest brew: how much one press fills
This is the largest single brew the maker lists. Every Keurig here stops at 12 oz except the K-Classic, which tops out at 10 (6, 8 or 10 oz, per CNN Underscored). The Ninja PB051 brews up to 24 oz from grounds, the biggest here, though Ninja's pod sizes stop at 12. Shop TODAY measured a 10-ounce brew from grounds at a little over four minutes on a cold start, and from a pod at just under a minute and a half.
Nespresso's numbers come from the capsules. The Vertuo Pop+, VertuoPlus, Lattissima and Creatista all list the 535 ml (about 18 oz) carafe capsule. The Vertuo Next tops out at its 14 oz Alto. The Essenza Mini and CitiZ & Milk are espresso machines at heart, with factory settings of 40 ml for espresso and 110 ml (about 3.7 oz) for lungo. You can reprogram both buttons, but a travel mug isn't what they're for. The Lavazza Classy Plus makes one 8 oz coffee, according to Lavazza.
The Vertuo Pop+ and VertuoPlus brew Nespresso's 18 oz carafe capsules, so they can fill a carafe.
Both manuals list the carafe capsule as suitable but put Nespresso's own carafe under "not suitable accessories". Check that your carafe or mug actually fits under the spout before you buy carafe capsules.
The catch: a bigger cup isn't free. TechGearLab's taste panel found the K-Mini's coffee light and the K-Express's watery at a standard 8 oz, and stretching one pod to 12 oz won't make it stronger.
Water tank: how often you refill
The tank sets how many cups you get between trips to the sink, and the range here is huge.
The big tanks are the K-Supreme Plus SMART (78 oz), K-Elite (75), K-Duo (72), Bruvi (70), Vertuo Creatista (2 L, about 68 oz) and K-Supreme (66). The K-Mini sits at the other end. You pour in 6 to 12 oz for each brew, which TechGearLab calls "not ideal for those who want a huge cup of coffee in the morning." The Vertuo Pop+ isn't much roomier at 0.75 L (25.4 oz) per Nespresso's manual, and Good Housekeeping UK's testers had to top up the similar Vertuo Pop more often than other machines.
Tank size also shows up in how a machine heats. TechGearLab found that the K-Elite and K-Classic pull water in and heat it before brewing, which makes the first cup slow and the next ones fast.
Pay up only if: more than one person drinks coffee in your house. For one cup a day, a 40 oz tank is plenty, and the smaller machine leaves you more counter space.
Brews your own grounds: the escape hatch from pods
Twelve of the 20 can brew your own ground coffee. The Ninja PB051 and Cuisinart DGB-2 have it built in: the Ninja swaps between a pod holder and a grounds basket, and the Cuisinart grinds whole beans straight into a reusable filter cup. Good Housekeeping found the extra grinding step paid off with flavorful, medium-bodied cups. The K-Duo uses grounds in its drip-carafe side. Every other Keurig here works with Keurig's My K-Cup reusable filter, and TechGearLab ran its whole Keurig taste test with reusable K-Cups. Bruvi sells its own reusable pods, according to CNN Underscored.
None of the Nespressos take grounds without third-party gadgets, and neither does the Lavazza Classy Plus, whose maker lists only Expert capsules.
What the box won't tell you: a reusable filter turns a pod machine into a small drip brewer. That saves money on pods, but TechGearLab put it bluntly: with refillable pods, "you're basically making drip coffee."
Milk frother: lattes without a second gadget
Six of the 20 make milk foam out of the box. The Nespresso Vertuo Lattissima has a milk carafe built in, and Consumer Reports named it the best Vertuo brewer. The Vertuo Creatista has a steam wand with separate milk temperature and texture buttons, per Nespresso's manual. The CitiZ & Milk ships with Nespresso's Aeroccino, and Food & Wine called it whisper-quiet. The Lavazza Classy Plus froths milk in its own vessel. The Keurig K-Café SMART has a frother for hot or cold foam plus 2 or 4 oz coffee shots, and Consumer Reports named it the best K-Cup brewer. The Ninja PB051 has a fold-away frother, but Good Housekeeping notes it doesn't heat milk, so you warm the milk first.
The Vertuo Pop+ doesn't come with one; Nespresso sells the Aeroccino separately.
Don't overpay for: a frother you'll use twice. TechGearLab liked that the K-Café can froth hot and cold milk, but flagged its coffee as bitter.
Iced setting: brew over ice without watering it down
Eight of the 20 have a dedicated iced or over-ice setting: the K-Supreme, K-Supreme Plus SMART, K-Elite, K-Café SMART, K-Iced, K-Duo, Ninja PB051 and Bruvi BV-01. Keurig says its Brew Over Ice setting starts hotter to pull out flavor, then cools down so less ice melts. None of the Nespressos have one. The Vertuo Pop+ has a concentrate mode, a quick double press that makes a stronger brew for recipes with milk, creamer or ice, but it isn't an iced button.
Having the button doesn't guarantee good iced coffee. TechGearLab ranked the K-Iced, the machine named after the feature, last in its Keurig test for taste and splashing.
The catch: if iced coffee is the main event, the Ninja and Bruvi are the best-reviewed machines here that have an iced setting. The K-Iced is the one reviewers didn't like.
Which single-serve coffee maker to buy
For most kitchens, get the Ninja Pods & Grounds PB051. Good Housekeeping named it the best value, Shop TODAY gave its brew quality top marks, and it's the only machine here that does K-Cups, grounds, 24 oz, iced and a frother. If you're staying with K-Cups and want the best cup, get the K-Supreme Plus SMART, or the plain K-Supreme, which TechGearLab called the best Keurig for most people. For Nespresso, the VertuoPlus was Good Housekeeping's pick, the Vertuo Pop+ is the small, cheaper way in, and the Vertuo Lattissima is the one to get for milk drinks. If taste comes first and you can live with online-only pods, the Bruvi BV-01 was CNN Underscored's favorite. If you'd rather brew a full pot most days, our drip coffee maker sheet is the better place to look, and the espresso machine sheet covers machines that don't need pods.
Single-serve coffee maker FAQ
Is Nespresso better than Keurig? For taste, labs usually say yes. TechGearLab says Nespresso models consistently outperform K-Cups in its tests. Keurig wins on choice: Consumer Reports notes K-Cups come in far more brands and blends. If you drink coffee black or with a splash of milk, Nespresso is worth it. If you want variety from the supermarket aisle, stay with Keurig.
Does pod coffee taste as good as drip? Usually not. Consumer Reports says pod coffee most likely won't match the taste of a top-performing drip brewer and isn't as fresh-tasting. That's why its pod tests focus on speed, consistency and convenience. If flavor matters most, a machine that brews your own grounds, like the Cuisinart DGB-2 with its built-in grinder, gets you closer.
How often should you descale a single-serve coffee maker? Experts quoted by Shop TODAY suggest descaling a Keurig every three to six months and a Nespresso about every three months or 300 capsules. The time it takes varies a lot. TechGearLab timed about 20 minutes on the K-Supreme and K-Express, against 45 to 75 minutes on the K-Mini and K-Duo.
Can a Vertuo machine use Original capsules? No. Vertuo machines only take Vertuo capsules, which carry a barcode the machine reads to set the brew, as Good Housekeeping explains. Original capsules fit Original machines like the Essenza Mini and CitiZ & Milk. Pick the system first, because the capsules aren't interchangeable.
Sources / further reading
- Good Housekeeping: 6 best single-serve coffee makers, according to expert testing
- CNN Underscored: best single-serve coffee makers, tested and reviewed
- Consumer Reports: best single-serve coffee makers, lab-tested and reviewed
- TechGearLab: the best Keurig coffee maker
- Shop TODAY: ranked, the best single-serve coffee makers
- Food & Wine: the best Nespresso machines, according to our tests
- Tom's Guide: Keurig K-Duo Hot & Iced review
- Good Housekeeping UK: best Nespresso machines, tested by experts
- Nespresso Vertuo Pop+ user manual
- Lavazza: Classy Plus